When Millicent Rogers walked into the gallery, it fell silent. Santa Fe was already a quiet place, but this was more like a deep hush.
She had just stepped into the Gerald Peters Gallery opening in 1947, wearing a simple black dress and her signature turquoise cuff. One piece of jewelry. One statement. Complete command.
The Standard Oil heiress had perfected an effortless presence. Something most people spend their lifetimes chasing. So while her peers layered on pearls and diamonds like armor, she knew that real elegance is supposed to whisper… not shout.
Issue forwarded by a friend? Subscribe here.
Rogers wasn’t supposed to become a style icon. Even though she was born into the Standard Oil super family, she was supposed to play her part as a “society wife.” Instead, she said screw that and did something that was radical for the time. She moved to Taos, New Mexico, in the 1940s and fell in love with Native American artistry.
To be clear, this wasn’t some rich lady hobby. Rogers engulfed herself in the Native American culture. She learned traditional silversmithing techniques, studied turquoise quality, and even built relationships with Pueblo artisans. In her mind, you couldn’t just buy pretty things… real style came from understanding the craft.
It was completely out of pocket for her to take this approach. While Manhattan socialities competed with elaborate jewelry collections, Rogers built her entire aesthetic around turquoise and silver. And it was all centered around her personal philosophy.
Rogers stuck to one simple rule, and that was one piece commands attention and everything else supports it. But it’s not minimalism by any means. It’s about strategic visual design. She learned that the human eye can only process one focal point, and she leaned into that.
For example, when she put together her outfits, a turquoise cuff was her statement piece and her earrings would be small silver studs (designed to complement). If she wore a squash blossom necklace, her hands only had her simple wedding ring. And that same principle applies whether your statement piece is a chunky watch, a ring, or a quality leather bracelet. She never put two pieces together to compete for attention.
When you think about it technically, the chunky turquoise cuff carries significant presence, so everything else in the outfit needs to take a step back.
Take a moment right now to think about your last formal event. Pull up that photo on your phone. Count the pieces you wore. How many were trying to make a statement? If the answer is more than one, then you know exactly what Rogers would have fixed.
Rogers had an obsession with how things were made, not just how they looked. She could point out machine made “Native American style” jewelry from a mile away. And she wasn’t trying to be a snob. She was looking for things that were different. Handmade jewelry that had irregularities and caught light differently. Jewelry that aged beautifully. Pieces that carried stories in their construction…
You can do this too. You can develop an eye like Rogers to find quality. When you’re out shopping, look for hand finished edges on metalwork, natural stone variations, and weight that shows solid construction.
I remember walking into the Turquoise Tortoise Gallery in Sedona about a month ago. It felt different, and you could tell right away. James Little’s work exemplified Rogers' philosophy. Hand hammered silver and carefully selected stones.
Studying places like this can give you an understanding of how handwork creates a presence that mass produced products just can’t.
Everyone has a signature style. When you think of Elvis, you think slicked back hair. When you look at Billie Eilish you think baggy with sophistication. Think Johnny Cash's black everything, or how Steve Jobs made the simple black turtleneck his signature.
Rogers was the one who created “signature style.” Turquoise and silver were her visual language. She appeared in a ton of different combinations, but it was always recognized as hers. People were always interested in what she had to wear, because they never knew what to expect even though she was so consistent.
But this doesn’t mean you wear identical pieces all the time. It means creating a profile for yourself and exploring variations. Let’s say your style is vintage gold and pearls. Maybe it’s colorful. The goal is to choose something that resonates with your personal aesthetic and then explore its depth instead of jumping between trends. People remember consistency more than novelty.
Ok, so now you know what it takes to build a specific jewelry aesthetic, but how do you actually do it today?
It does require investment, but not at the prices you might expect. What you need to do is look for specific construction markers: hand finished bezels around stones, slightly irregular marks that show it’s handmade, holding it in your hand to feel the weight and how solid it is…
When you visit the jewelry store or an artisan, ask about their techniques. Can they explain how they set stones? Do they hand forge their silver or cast it? If it’s a quality maker, you’ll know. They love discussing their process. If it’s mass produced, they will deflect those types of questions.
When you’re thinking about buying, the one question to ask yourself is how will this age?
Classic techniques and timeless portions matter more than trendiness. Rogers’ 1940s pieces look as sophisticated today as they did then because they were built on solid aesthetic principles, not passing fashion trends.
If you’re looking to invest in statement pieces, find a well-made necklace, quality watch, distinctive ring, or statement bracelet in your preferred metal. You don’t need everything at once. Rogers took years to build her collection, adding pieces as she went… making sure it matched her aesthetic and not going against it.
This weekend, someone will walk into a room and command attention without saying a word.
Their jewelry won’t be the most expensive, but it will be intentional. People will remember them, wonder about them, and want to know their story.
That person could be you, or you could keep doing what everyone else does… layer on multiple pieces, chase trends, hoping that “more” equals better.
Rogers figured out that presence isn’t about what you own, it’s about what you choose. And choice, unlike wealth or natural beauty, is available to everyone. The only question is if you’re brave enough to use it.
Thank you for reading! Let us know what you thought of this issue by replying directly to this email. Cheers 🥂
Join 2,089 readers 💃🕺🏽
